Merit Increase: Meaning, How It is Calculated, Pros, Cons, and Common Mistakes to Avoid

The salary hike you receive after your annual performance review is known as the merit increase. This is awarded to an employee based on their performance, achievements, and contributions at work. 

A well-managed merit increase can boost employee confidence, the organization’s ROI, and work engagement. In this article, you will get to know the merit increase meaning, and how it is different from a “raise” and a “promotion,” along with the pros, cons, and common mistakes. 

What Is a Merit Increase?

A merit increase is a base pay adjustment that can be granted to an employee based on their performance. Employees typically receive a merit increase through an evaluation process. However, the size of the merit increase is determined by the overall performance, rather than every employee receiving the same amount of raise. 

Employees may hear a variety of names for a merit increase, including merit raise, merit-based raise, merit pay increase, and annual merit increase. All these terms refer to a merit increase.

The key differentiators of a merit increase include: 

• Merit increases are always calculated using a percentage of an employee’s current salary.
• A merit increase is permanent. 
• Once earned, an employee has this new increased base salary until he/she retires from the company. A one-time bonus does not become part of the employee’s base salary.

Merit Increase Definition

An employee’s base salary or hourly wage permanently increases due to his/her individual performance. This type of pay increase is usually given to employees at the end of each fiscal year when they are evaluated.

Merit Increase vs Raise vs Promotion

Check out the difference between the merit increase, raise, and promotion that are often confused with the same meaning. 

Factor	Merit Increase	Raise	Promotion
Meaning	Salary increase based on an employee’s performance and achievements.	An increase in salary, often due to market adjustments, inflation, or company policies.	Advancement to a higher job level or positions within the organization.
Main Reason	Rewarding good or exceptional performance.	Adjusting compensation to meet market rates, inflation, or salary policies.	Recognized increased skills, capabilities, or readiness for a higher role.
Job Title	Usually remains the same.	Usually remains the same.	Sometimes changes are needed to reflect the new role or level.
Responsibilities	Remains the same most of the time.	Usually remains the same.	Typically increase with greater accountability and authority.
Performance Dependency	Highly dependent on individual performance feedback.	May or may not depend on the individual performance review.	Usually depends on performance skills, experience, and readiness for the next level.
Salary Impact	Usually a percentage increase based on performance and salary range.	Can be a fixed amount or percentage increase.	Often comes with a larger salary increase aligned with the new role or grade.
Time Duration	Typically during the annual or periodic performance review cycle.	Can occur annually or whenever market or policy adjustments are made.	Occurs when an employee is selected for and moves into a higher-level role.

How Is a Merit Increase Calculated?

A merit increase can be determined through the calculation of an employee’s current base rate being multiplied by the percent of the raise (merit) and added to their salary. Most times, the percent that is used is based on a performance rating as well as an employee’s place within their pay range. 

The formula: 

Increase amount= current salary x increase %

New salary = current salary + increase amount

Increase % = (new salary – old salary) / old salary x 100

Example

Your salary is $50,000, and you earn a 4% merit increase.

Increase = $50,000 × 0.04 = $2,000

New salary = $52,000, or about $4,333 a month before tax

Who Qualifies for a Merit Increase?

Each employer defines how they determine the qualifications for a merit pay increase. Some common determinants of merit increase include: 

• Employee performance rating from the most recent evaluation. 
• Length of time working in this job or with the company, because many employers have a minimum amount of time required prior to participating in the merit increase process. 
• Budget constraints and financial situation of the company.
• Position in your pay range.

How Often Are Merit Increases Given?

Most employers give merit increases annually as part of their performance review and budget process. An established schedule will help the managers, HR, and finance department know what to expect.

Note to Remember

Performance reviews occur in a specific time frame, usually during a designated period. Discussing your potential increase beforehand can help you have a greater impact on your total increase.

Most of the common timeframes when a merit increase is given are: 

• Annually (Most Common): Most companies evaluate employee appreciation and performance and determine merit increases one time per year.
• Semi-annual: Some companies evaluate employees’ work and award pay increases two times each year.
• Quarterly or Project-Based (Rare): While less common, some companies distribute merit increases either every quarter or immediately upon completion of significant projects.

How to Get a Merit Increase (Employee Guide)?

To earn a merit increase, know your criteria, document your results, and start the conversation before budgets lock. Check out the step-by-step on how to get a merit increase at work.

Step 1: Know How Your Company Decides 

Find out what your company uses to decide who gets a merit. What are their rating scales? When do they review employees? Are there any specific rules that must be followed to be eligible for a merit?

Step 2: Set Goals with your Managers 

Work with your managers to set measurable goals. This will help them understand performance when it comes time for your review. 

Step 3: Track all your Wins 

Keep track of all of the things you achieve throughout the year. Write down results, statistics, and any positive feedback you receive from coworkers or managers.

Step 4: Check Where you Stand in Relation to Market Pay

Compare salaries based on job title, city/state, and years of experience to find out where you rank compared to others in your industry. 

Step 5: Book Slot for Dedicated Discussions

Schedule an appointment with your manager about three to four months before your review.

Step 6: Show Evidence to Support your Request

When asking for a merit, lead with your accomplishments. Quantify your achievements, instead of just saying I did something. 

Step 7: Ask What Would Get You to the Next Level

If your manager tells you that you won’t be receiving a merit this year, ask them what you could do differently to reach the next level.

Pros and Cons of Merit-Based Pay

Pros	Cons
Rewarded for outstanding job performance.	Creates stress and frustration when an employee fails to meet expectations.
The retention rate of the top talent is high.	Individual performance will likely outweigh team success.
Attracts candidates who want pay linked to performance.	Managerial bias is pointed out.
Encourages growth in the organization.

Common Merit Increase Mistakes

Many issues arise because of poorly defined evaluation criteria, lack of effective communication with employees, and uneven decision-making. Hence, the following are mentioned below:

• Poorly defined job performance evaluations can impact the merit increase rate. 
• There is no correlation between how well you were rated on your performance and the size of your salary increase. 
• Lack of calibration among managers; therefore, the same level of performance can result in different levels of outcome. 
• In some companies, merit-based increases are treated as if they are the only way to retain employees.
• Failure to communicate the reasoning behind a small pay increase impacts the decision-making processes. 

Insights 

According to Payscale, 36% of U.S. organizations gave across-the-board raises in 2026, 32% plan to do so in 2027, and 25% reported losing talent due to insufficient pay increases.

Conclusion 

A merit increase is an easy concept to describe; however, it’s extremely difficult to implement. However, with multiple new hires over time, managing increases quickly becomes complicated. Do you need all of your employee evaluations, records, and reviews in one area as part of your evaluation cycle? See how Managetrix can help your team during your review process.

FAQs